The Good, The Bad and The Critic

Established on March 19th, 2012 and pioneered by film fanatic Michael J. Carlisle. The Good, The Bad and The Critic will analyze classic and contemporary films from all corners of the globe. This title references Sergei Leone's influential spaghetti western The Good, The Bad and the Ugly.

Sunday, March 16, 2014

Brief Encounter Review- By Michael Carlisle

 Title: Brief Encounter
Year: 1945

Director: David Lean
Country: UK
Language: English

For an impeccable analysis on David Lean's Brief Encounter please read Michael W. Boyce's The Lasting Influence of the War on Postwar British Film which is available at Amazon and/or your local library. It contains a wealth of knowledge on this film, as well as quite a few others ( Carol Reed's The Third Man for instance) Though I will try my best to dissect this classic, this review will seem pauperized.

At a café on a railway station, housewife Laura Jesson (Celia Johnson) meets doctor Alec Harvey (Trevor Howard). Although they are both already married, they gradually fall in love with each other. They continue to meet every Thursday in the small cafe, however they know that their love is impossible. 

In 1999 The British Film Institute produced their list of 100 Greatest British films in their cinematic history. To no surprise Carol Reed's The Third Man made top place, while Lean's Brief Encounter made runner up.  Encounter is the embodiment of a genre that has faded from public mindset; the woman's picture. Tragic melodramas obsessed with the life not lived, the road not traveled and what potentially could be. While modern chick-flicks give women wish fulfillment, they can have anything they want, Lean gives us miles of self denial.

Laura and Alec display a miserable self control that is hard to fathom in any setting other than post-war Britain. It's been labelled the "British Casablanca", I suppose the sacrifice element is similar, but while Rick and Iilsa had the Nazis to contend with, Laura and Alec have the institution of marriage, which is a much smaller threat. Though sex is dealt with indirectly, it is very much the driving force of the film. " "If we control ourselves, and behave like sensible human beings ..." Laura offers, knowing that it is incredibly difficult to show restraint. Both actors have such great onscreen chemistry that it made this subject matter even more scandalous in the 40's.

In conclusion, even 69 years after its theatrical debut Lean's Brief Encounter is a tremendous tearjerker. I've seen most of the Director's astonishing filmography, which includes works like Lawrence of Arabia and Great Expectations, and I feel that this is his greatest accomplishment. See it because films like this aren't made any more. Praise it! 5/5

No comments:

Post a Comment